My Physician Partner Is Buying Me Out at a Number I Can’t Accept. How Does a Physician Buyout Valuation Dispute Work in California?

November 20, 2026 | By Law Offices Of Parag L Amin, P.C.
My Physician Partner Is Buying Me Out at a Number I Can’t Accept. How Does a Physician Buyout Valuation Dispute Work in California?

You and your physician partner built this practice together. Now your partner wants to buy out your share, whether they are retiring, bringing in a new doctor, or moving in a different direction, and the number on the table feels wrong. You are in a physician buyout valuation dispute, and how you handle the next few conversations can affect what you are paid.

Maybe the offer is based only on your capital account balance. Maybe it comes from a formula in an old buy-sell agreement that neither of you has read closely in years. Maybe nothing is in writing, just an understanding from the day you both signed on. However the number arrived, the gap between what you believe your share is worth and what your partner is offering can be large. You spent years building a patient base, a reputation, and an ownership stake. California law gives you more ways to push back than many physicians realize.

Why This Matters Right Now

Buy-sell and shareholder agreements often set tight windows once a buyout is triggered: a short period to name an appraiser, a deadline to object to a proposed price, or a notice period that starts the moment your partner raises the subject. If those windows close while you are still deciding how you feel about the number, you may lose leverage you did not know you had.

There is also a practical problem. Your partner likely controls, or has easier access to, the books, the accountant, and the billing data that any valuation depends on. The longer a disagreement drags on without independent numbers, the more your partner's figure starts to look like the default answer, simply because nobody challenged it. If your partner has also started shutting you out of decisions or records, the buyout offer may be part of a larger pattern, like the one described in our post on being frozen out by a business partner.

Does My Buy-Sell Agreement Control the Price in a Physician Buyout Valuation Dispute?

Start with your own paperwork, not a statute. Your buy-sell, shareholder, or partnership agreement may establish the valuation method or process that governs the transaction. If those provisions are clear and enforceable under applicable California law, they may control the buyout price even when one party considers the result unfair. Some agreements set a fixed formula, such as a multiple of trailing collections, or book value plus a defined goodwill add-on. Others set a process instead of a number: each side names an appraiser, the two appraisers choose a third if they disagree, and the price becomes an average of the closest figures.

Read the agreement carefully before you accept or reject any number. Ambiguity is where real fights start: an undefined term like “fair value,” a formula tied to a metric the practice no longer tracks the same way, or language written for a two-doctor practice that never anticipated the associates or ancillary services added later.

What If the Formula No Longer Matches How the Practice Makes Money?

Many practices add imaging, physical therapy, ambulatory procedures, or more associate physicians over the years, and an older agreement may never have contemplated them. Disputes often center on whether that newer revenue counts toward the buyout number at all, or whether your partner treats it as a separate asset that stays with the practice no matter how the core formula reads. If your agreement predates a major change in how the practice earns money, flag that mismatch early, before you sign off on a number.

What If There Is No Buy-Sell Agreement, or It Says Nothing About Valuation?

A missing or silent agreement does not leave you without options. If the practice is a general partnership and the statutory buyout provisions apply, California Corporations Code section 16701 establishes a default valuation framework for a dissociated partner’s interest. The buyout price generally reflects what the partner would receive if the business were sold at the greater of its liquidation value or its value as a going concern without that partner, subject to applicable adjustments, offsets, and interest. If the parties cannot agree on a price within 120 days after a written demand for payment, the partnership generally must pay its estimated buyout amount in cash, although limited circumstances may permit deferred payment.

The payment or tender must include specified financial information, an explanation of how the amount was calculated, and written notice that it will be treated as full satisfaction of the obligation to purchase unless the partner sues in time. Under section 16701(i), a dissociated partner generally has 120 days after the partnership tenders payment or an offer to pay to bring an action challenging the amount. If no payment or offer is tendered, the deadline is generally one year after written demand. A court can determine the proper buyout price and may award attorney’s fees and expert expenses when a party has acted arbitrarily, vexatiously, or not in good faith. Because these deadlines can affect the right to challenge the valuation, early legal review is important.

If the practice is a professional medical corporation instead, the partnership dissociation statute does not apply in the same way, and the fallback runs through the corporate dissolution and buyout statutes covered below.

How Is a Share Valued in a Physician Buyout Valuation Dispute?

When a formula does not control, or the parties dispute whether it applies, valuation experts typically use one or more of three recognized approaches. The income approach capitalizes the practice’s adjusted net earnings, or projects and discounts future cash flow. It often carries the most weight for a medical practice, because the practice’s value comes from its ability to keep generating income, not from the depreciated value of its exam tables and equipment. The market approach compares the practice to recent sales of similar practices in the same specialty and region. The asset approach considers the fair market value of the practice’s tangible and intangible assets, less applicable liabilities. Depending on the circumstances and the governing valuation standard, it may provide another useful measure of the practice’s value.

Why Add-Backs Can Move the Number

Appraisers often blend the approaches, and a large part of any valuation fight is the adjustments layered on top of the raw numbers. A common flashpoint is the add-back: an adjustment that raises adjusted net earnings by removing above-market owner compensation, personal expenses run through the practice, or one-time costs that will not recur. Push add-backs too far in either direction and the valuation shifts sharply. That is why an independent expert who works for you, not for the practice as a whole, matters.

Personal Goodwill vs. Enterprise Goodwill: Where the Real Fight Happens

One of the most contested issues in a physician buyout is how much of the practice’s value is personal goodwill and how much is enterprise goodwill. Personal goodwill is tied to an individual physician’s skill, reputation, and direct patient relationships. Enterprise goodwill is tied to the practice itself: its systems, brand, location, and referral relationships that survive any one physician’s departure. How a given amount of value is classified depends on the facts and the valuation standard that applies.

California Business and Professions Code section 16600 generally prohibits agreements restricting a person’s ability to practice a lawful profession, subject to limited statutory exceptions. Section 16601 permits certain restrictions arising from qualifying sales of business interests and goodwill, but not every physician buyout satisfies that exception. Whether a restriction is enforceable depends on the transaction’s structure, the goodwill transferred, and other applicable legal requirements.

These rules can influence valuation negotiations. Your partner may argue that some of the practice’s value comes from your personal reputation and patient relationships rather than goodwill belonging to the business. The distinction can affect what each side believes the ownership interest is worth, although the applicable valuation standard and the parties’ agreement remain important.

Can the Courts Help Resolve a Buyout Dispute?

When negotiation stalls and the problem is genuine deadlock or unfair conduct, not an ordinary disagreement over price, a shareholder of a California corporation may be able to petition for involuntary dissolution under Corporations Code section 1800. Standing is limited. Among those eligible are shareholders meeting the statutory 33 1/3 percent ownership threshold, calculated according to section 1800, and shareholders of qualifying close corporations. In certain misconduct-based cases, shares owned by persons who personally participated in the specified wrongdoing are excluded from the ownership calculation. The grounds include a deadlock among shareholder factions that keeps the business from being conducted to advantage, and persistent and pervasive fraud, mismanagement, abuse of authority, or persistent unfairness toward a shareholder by those in control.

A section 1800 petition may lead to a buyout under Corporations Code section 2000. Subject to the statute and any contrary provision in the corporation’s articles, the corporation or qualifying shareholders may elect to purchase the petitioning shareholder’s interest at fair value instead of allowing dissolution to proceed. Fair value is determined using liquidation value as of the applicable valuation date, taking into account the possibility of selling the entire business as a going concern in liquidation. If the parties cannot agree on the amount, the court appoints three disinterested appraisers. The award of the appraisers, or a majority of them, becomes final and conclusive when confirmed by the court, subject to applicable procedures and appeal rights.

This is a serious step, not a first move. Its availability still matters, because when both sides know a court-supervised appraisal is the alternative, it can push a stalled negotiation toward a more realistic number. The fair value standard can cut both ways, so it deserves careful study before anyone files. Our post on shareholder buyout disputes in California covers this process in more detail.

Who Is Allowed to Buy My Share? California’s Ownership Rules for Medical Corporations

California’s corporate practice of medicine doctrine limits who can own a stake in a medical practice, and that shapes what a buyout can look like. Under the Moscone-Knox Professional Corporation Act (Corporations Code sections 13400 through 13410), shares in a professional medical corporation are limited to licensed professionals, primarily physicians, with limited room for certain other licensed health care providers whose combined ownership cannot exceed 49 percent. California also generally does not allow a limited liability company to render professional services that require a license, including medical services (Corporations Code section 17701.04(e)).

In practical terms, a physician shareholder generally cannot sell shares in a professional medical corporation directly to an unlicensed outside investor, management services organization, or private equity fund. Corporations Code sections 13401.5 and 13407 restrict who may own or receive those shares, although certain licensed health care professionals may qualify. A buyout may involve a repurchase by the corporation or a transfer to another legally eligible purchaser. These restrictions can complicate financing and payment arrangements, particularly when the practice lacks sufficient cash or credit to fund the transaction.

Senate Bill 351 (Chapter 409, Statutes of 2025), effective January 1, 2026, added Division 1.7 (commencing with section 1190) to the Health and Safety Code. The law restricts private equity groups and hedge funds involved with California physician and dental practices from interfering with specified clinical and operational decisions. It also restricts certain noncompete and nondisparagement provisions in covered arrangements. If outside capital is part of the proposed buyout, the transaction’s structure should be reviewed for compliance with these requirements and California’s existing medical corporation ownership rules.

What NOT to Do While You Are Negotiating

Do not sign a resignation, a release, or an acceptance of a proposed valuation under a deadline your partner set until your own attorney has reviewed it. A signature given on a short fuse can give up claims you did not know you had.

Do not rely on a valuation prepared only by the practice’s own accountant. That person typically works for the entity or for your partner, not for you personally, even if the relationship has always been friendly.

Do not cut your patient load or clinical hours out of frustration while the earnings figures behind an income-approach valuation are being calculated. A drop in your own production can lower the very number you are fighting to protect.

Do not miss a notice, objection, or appraiser-selection deadline buried in an old buy-sell agreement. A missed deadline can waive rights.

Do not discuss the dispute with staff, patients, or referral sources in a way that could be read as disparagement or interference with the practice while the buyout is pending.

Documents to Gather

Pulling these together before you speak with an attorney saves time and lets the attorney see your position quickly.

  • The written partnership, shareholder, or buy-sell agreement, along with every amendment.
  • Three to five years of practice tax returns and financial statements.
  • Payer mix, collections, and ancillary service revenue reports.
  • Your capital account statements and any buy-in documents.
  • Any earlier valuation or appraisal of the practice, even an informal one.
  • All written communication about the proposed price, including emails and texts.

When to Bring in an Attorney

A few signals suggest it is time to bring in a medical practice dispute lawyer rather than keep negotiating directly. Your partner has already hired a valuation expert or an attorney and you have not. Your buy-sell agreement is silent, ambiguous, or clearly outdated compared with how the practice runs today. You suspect you are being pressured, sidelined from decisions, or cut off from records ahead of the valuation. A notice or election deadline is approaching, or the partnership has tendered a payment or offer that starts a deadline to challenge it. Or the offer is far below what comparable practices in your specialty and region have sold for. Any one of these is reason enough for a second set of eyes.

The Takeaway

A disagreement over what your share is worth does not mean you have to accept your partner’s number. Your buy-sell agreement, California’s partnership and corporate statutes, and standard valuation methods all give you leverage, but only if you use them before you sign. Get your own picture of the practice’s finances, and your own counsel, involved early, while your options are still open.

Call to Action

If you are facing a physician buyout valuation dispute, the sooner you get counsel involved, the more options you have. LawPLA works with California business owners statewide, including physicians and medical practice owners, to protect their business, livelihood, and legacy. Call our office at 213-293-7881 or reach us through our contact page to discuss your case.


Disclaimer: This blog post is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship between you and the Law Offices of Parag L. Amin, P.C. Also, things may have changed since this blog was written and the outcomes depend on the specific facts of each matter. You should not rely solely on this blog for your next steps, and you should seek the advice of competent counsel licensed in your jurisdiction about your particular situation. If you need help, contact us today at (213) 293-7881 to evaluate your matter.